Shingles, Brava composite shake or new cedar. Honest costs, fire ratings and lifespans, from the crew that has converted cedar roofs across the region.
Cedar shake roofs were the standard across the Lower Mainland for decades, and thousands are now past 25 years, mossed over, split and leaking. Replacing one is different from a shingle re-roof: cedar sits on skip sheathing with gaps between boards, so whatever goes on next needs a new solid deck first. Stonnex has converted cedar roofs across Vancouver, Abbotsford, Mission and the North Shore, and we are a Brava Preferred Contractor for homeowners who want the cedar look without the cedar.
This page lays out the three honest paths: architectural shingles, Brava composite shake, or new cedar, with the cost, lifespan and fire-rating implications of each.
$7.50 to $11.50 per sq ft installed including the new deck. 20 to 30 years. Class A fire rating. The right answer for most homes where the look is not the priority.
Indistinguishable from hand-split cedar at the curb, Class A fire rated, 50-year transferable warranty, no moss treatment ever. Priced per project; see our Brava page.
The authentic material, 15 to 25 years on the wet coast with regular treatment. Class C fire rating unless treated; increasingly restricted by municipal bylaws and insurers.
A fourth option on contemporary homes: 50-plus years, Class A, $13 to $19 per sq ft. Changes the look entirely, so it suits some houses and not others.
Cedar shakes are nailed to 1x4 or 1x6 skip sheathing with air gaps that let the wood dry. Shingles, composite shake and metal all need a continuous deck. A cedar conversion therefore includes removing the shakes and the skip sheathing (or sheathing over it where the structure allows), installing new plywood across the entire roof, then building the new roof on top. The plywood alone is 60 to 80 sheets on a typical home, which is why the installed range of $7.50 to $11.50 per square foot sits above a standard shingle replacement.
A recent example: a cedar-to-shingle conversion in Abbotsford involved full shake removal, a new 1/2-inch plywood deck, synthetic underlayment, ice and water membrane at all eaves and valleys, and architectural shingles, completed over four working days.
Untreated cedar is a Class C roof covering. Several Lower Mainland municipalities now restrict new untreated wood roofs in wildland interface zones, and some insurers surcharge or decline homes with cedar roofs. Architectural shingles, Brava composite shake and metal are all Class A, the highest rating. If you are in an interface area on the North Shore, in Maple Ridge, Mission, Abbotsford or the Fraser Valley hillsides, this alone often decides the material. Our cedar shake fire rules guide covers the municipal detail.
For heritage homes in Shaughnessy and Kerrisdale, West Vancouver character properties and anywhere the cedar profile is part of the architecture, Brava composite shake is the material we recommend most often. It is moulded from real hand-split cedar, colour runs through the full thickness of the tile, it carries a Class A rating and a 50-year transferable warranty, and it never needs moss treatment or oiling. Stonnex is one of the few Brava Preferred Contractors in British Columbia. Details, colours and completed projects are on our Brava page; costs are in the Brava cost guide, and a side-by-side is in Brava versus real cedar.
At that point, pressure-washing and treating is money spent on a roof with two or three years left. A free inspection gives you a written answer and a quote for whichever path suits the house. Full pricing method is in the roof replacement cost guide, or call 604-935-6976.
Free inspection, no obligation. We respond within one business day.
Book Free Inspection 604-935-6976"Professional from the first call to final cleanup. The crew was respectful of our property and the workmanship is outstanding. Highly recommend Stonnex."
"They gave us an honest assessment and a fair price. The roof looks beautiful and we felt informed at every step. This is how every contractor should operate."
"Quick response, quality work, and they cleaned up completely after. We had quotes from three companies and Stonnex was the clear choice."
We serve homeowners throughout Metro Vancouver and the Fraser Valley. Click your city for local reroofing information and pricing.
Full replacements for homes across the Lower Mainland.
Learn moreMembrane roofing for flat and low-slope applications.
Learn morePre-sale, insurance, and maintenance reports.
Learn moreFull tear-off and replacement with written warranty.
Learn more